Might as well.
I agree with the first of Xigo's complaints. You seem distracted by something else whenever we RP. If we're traveling, you'll keep auto-walking when we stop and you'll fall behind when we move again, and I don't mean you'll keep going/fall behind a short distance. I'm guilty of this as well, since I'm in an RP right now (with you) and writing this. Just check on WoW more often.
Nothing to say about characters besides "more anyone RP would be great". I should make a character to throw in with your night elves, but I'm allergic to alts.
Being new and all I am leery of putting in my two cents, but I second Xigo's and Mathias' statements. Soae has been around Anthrion more than a few times now and each time it was honestly, a bit awkward for me. You do seem distracted and because of this the rp was not enriching for either character. If he is meant to be aloof, strange, what not, then Soae definitely thinks that about him. It is almost to the point of wanting to avoid interacting with him on a social level.
At first I figured it was because you are a GM, you must be super busy. Then I saw you on Sareen last night and she was cracking me up! I don't think you were in the raid group when I said that her statement to the goblin about magical implants literally made me spit out my soda. Thanks for that it was great.
For a moment the nubbness in me made me wonder if perhaps you were only alt-tabbing during rp with me! Funny insecurities. Anywho, now that I see the distraction is consistent I don't feel so bad.
To end on a good note: I love your night elf centric events! I cannot wait to see what you have in store for us and know that I am more than willing to help out anytime. Not that you need it because you are doing great, but just cause.
Across the large swath of characters we RP across, I have seen a definite improvement in their diversity and individuality. I can't state anything specific, but it's there. I don't notice repeating behaviors. This even applies to the same character over the same type of RP. For instance, Anthrion training Kalah. We have not repeated one iota of that rather long and tedious storyline.
However, I do suggest planning out some RPs if anything then just to mix it up. Flying by the seat of your pants only gets you so far. It can add a whole new dimension, structure and productivity to a storyline you want to experience.
First post has been updated with a published google spreadsheet. This contains a list of all my characters, their classes, a brief description, and possible RP opportunities. Feel free to look over the list and poke me in-game for some RP, or find one in particular that you want to give some feedback for!
Can't see it
I think you should reconsider the characters you permit to enter your guild, or at least ease in their entry better. I've heard numerous complaints about non-Night Elves in the Ashwatch, and it's been made extremely awkward for them to justify the continued existence of their characters in your guild.
Don't be a pushover.
(08-27-2013, 08:07 AM)Memnoch Wrote: [ -> ]Can't see it
Weird, It should be accessible to all those on on the net. Never the less, there's a link
here if you want it!
(08-27-2013, 08:18 AM)Xigo Wrote: [ -> ]I think you should reconsider the characters you permit to enter your guild, or at least ease in their entry better. I've heard numerous complaints about non-Night Elves in the Ashwatch, and it's been made extremely awkward for them to justify the continued existence of their characters in your guild.
Don't be a pushover.
An understandable concern. It is a bit of a difficult position I'm in given that I want to try and accommodate as much as I can for RP, however it is getting to a bit of a ridiculous point. At this rate I may speak with those who are within and try to encourage some more fitting characters. We'll see.
Instead of trying to accommodate everyone, instead provide a clear and distinct 'mission' for the group.
'We are a human-only guild of nobility, leaning towards lawful-evilness.'
'We are a Horde-only guild of paramilitary members. Loyalty to the Horde is reqiured.'
'We are a bunch of people. Join if you want.'
What's the statement of the Asswash (sorry i had 2)? Is it...
'Night-Elf guild meant to protect Ashenvale/Kaldorei interests'?
Or
'Guild meant to protect Ashenvale'?
Because at the moment, it's not a guild that has Night Elf values, considering the presence of non-Alliance races in it.
Derp, it was AdBlock. Disabled for *.conquestofthehorde.com/* anyway, cause Google Ad Stuff helps @Kretol
Alright. Time to throw out some bait here.
Krilari. Anthrion. Ausar. The Argent Crusade (Especially the Mission Board). Possibly bringing back the Old Elf and the Sea as a more general, world event-centered story.
Feedback all of the above.
My only new feedback is about Ausar, who I enjoyed because I haven't really seen you play someone so unsure of themselves before (at least outwardly), so it was an interesting change of pace!
I don't think I usually give feedback on combat abilities, but here you go. I appreciated the way Anthrion blinked almost in the same spot, "a hair's width" as I recall to evade an attack. It wasn't the typical 'blink behind' or even every evade is a blink.
Likewise, when the enemy ran and put some distance between them and the raid you won the "highest roller gets the kill" routine. Instead of throwing knives or blinking, you simply pounded after the guy and cut him down using some of that Warden's expertise.
It's hard to put into words other than this; He is less "I am Warden. Worship me." and more genuine.
It's that time again. Feedback, folks. How am I doing? Comment on anything. IC, OOC, how I'm doing as a GM, my relatability , what I ate for breakfast, so on and so forth.
Your sleeping habits are atrocious!
Posted from my phone!
My RP with Tok'zi is still some of the best RP I've had since I returned to CotH. I'd really love to see more of him, and in general I'd like to catch you for more RP, though I admit I haven't been doing a very good job of making that clear.
Hit me up, person.